September 26 2022 6:58 AM E-paper Subscribe Sign in My Account Sign out

How illicit oil is smuggled into North Korea with China’s help

A satellite image from November 2020, provided by Maxar Technologies and analyzed by the think tank Royal United Services Institute (RUSI), shows half a dozen oil tankers in Sansha Bay, China, that have been publicly identified by the United Nations as providing illicit oil to North Korean ports or tankers. (Photo: NYTimes)
On a sunny, early morning in January, the oil tanker New Konk moved into a shipyard in China‘s Fujian province for repairs. It was an otherwise routine event, but for two details.اضافة اعلان

First, the ship‘s operators transmitted a false ship name, a deceptive practice often used to disguise a vessel‘s origins. And second, the New Konk had been identified by the United Nations (UN) in early 2020 for illicitly delivering oil to North Korea.

The ship was neither confiscated nor reported by Chinese authorities.
New satellite images obtained by The New York Times show that China has allowed the New Konk and similar tankers to use its infrastructure and territorial waters to smuggle oil into North Korea, undermining international sanctions.

The UN Security Council asks member states to impound vessels within their territory that are believed to be involved in sanctions violations.

Refined petroleum products such as fuel are not only crucial to North Korea‘s overall economy, but also to its nuclear and ballistic missile program, the target of the sanctions. Imports of refined petroleum products, currently capped at 500,000 barrels per year, are an essential pressure point for countries that favor strong economic penalties for North Korea.

China supported the UN Security Council resolution restricting North Korea‘s fuel imports. But the images show the country has been willing to turn a blind eye to violations.

The Shipyard

Satellite images commissioned and analyzed by The Times from the company Planet Labs show the New Konk on a river in the coastal city of Ningde, in eastern China, on January 1, 2021. The two images, taken about two hours apart, show the New Konk as it moved into the shipyard‘s dry dock, the area of a shipyard that is used for the repair or construction of vessels.

In order to track activities by ships such as the New Konk, the UN Security Council ‘s North Korea sanctions committee gets technical support from its Panel of Experts, which investigates and reports sanctions violations. China, a permanent member of the Council, is involved in deciding how to respond to the recommendations from the panel.

The new satellite images show that China has ignored some of those recommendations, including a global port ban.

“The UN panel reported the New Konk to the Security Council, China accepted the report, but allows this ship, recommended for a global port ban, into its dockyards for repair,” Hugh Griffiths, a consultant with expertise in sanctions and the former coordinator on the panel, said in a written statement on The Times’ findings. “This is not a good look.”

The Home Base

China‘s hands-off approach to tankers linked to North Korea is also visible in Sansha Bay, 49km southeast of the Ningde shipyard. The area has become a home base for oil tankers with ties to North Korea.

A satellite image from November 2020, analyzed by the think tank Royal United Services Institute (RUSI), shows half a dozen oil tankers that have been publicly identified by the UN as providing illicit oil to North Korean ports or tankers. Also visible is a Chinese navy boat, apparently patrolling the area.

One of the ships seen in the satellite images is the Diamond 8, a vessel at the center of a recent New York Times investigation and a new report by RUSI and the Center for Advanced Defense Studies, a think tank based in Washington.

“The UN panel recommendations, the photographs and satellite imagery provide reasonable grounds to believe that these vessels have violated the resolutions,” Griffiths said. “But at the moment, China is giving such vessels safe harbor.”

Another ship in Sansha Bay is the Yuk Tung, which the Security Council blacklisted in March 2018. China is obligated to take action against the Yuk Tung because it has been designated as having violated sanctions by the Security Council.

The ship has been sitting idle in Chinese waters since at least January 2020, according to a Times review of satellite imagery. Chinese authorities declined to respond when asked if the ship had been impounded or reported to the UN sanctions committee.

Instead, they provided a comment adapted from a December 2, 2020, press briefing from Hua Chunying, a spokeswoman for the Foreign Ministry, in which she called on the UN Security Council “to start discussions on rolling back sanctions” against North Korea.

A spokesperson for the United States Mission to the UN also declined to comment on the specifics of The Times‘ findings, but stated that “we expect UN Security Council members to lead by example.”

The Beneficiary

Over the last year, North Korea has expanded its oil infrastructure, building a new oil terminal in the major port of Nampo, where the oil tankers harbored in China regularly deliver their oil.

According to estimates by some UN member states, North Korea has exceeded the annual cap of 500,000 barrels per year since the measure took effect on January 1, 2018. Both China and Russia, another permanent member of the Security Council, have disputed these claims.

The Biden administration is expected to release details on its North Korea policy in the coming weeks. And its approach will likely depend on managing frosty relations with China, which President Joe Biden has described as the nation‘s most significant foreign policy challenge.

The goal of denuclearization is one area where US officials hope China and the United States can find common ground. But China‘s inactions regarding the tankers delivering oil to North Korea may stand in the way, said Griffiths.

“They negate some of the most important measures that would slow, if not halt, these UN prohibited programs.”