As Jordanian students gain more freedom to choose their academic paths, that choice has become less a matter of personal preference and more a balancing act between individual ambition and labor market reality. Educational experts say the growing gap between what students study and what employers need is creating overcrowding in some fields and leaving others under-resourced.
اضافة اعلان
Unrestricted choice does not guarantee balanced outcomes. When large numbers of students gravitate toward the same field, particularly one with limited job prospects for graduates, the mismatch between education and employment widens. This has raised a central question for policymakers: how to protect a student's right to choose while steering them toward fields the economy actually needs.
Guidance Must Start Years Before Enrollment
Faisal Tayeh, an educational expert, said achieving that balance cannot happen at the moment a student picks a specialization. It requires years of prior groundwork, built through career guidance that helps students understand their own abilities and the full range of academic and professional paths available to them.
Tayeh argued that career guidance should be embedded in the education system itself, not offered as an afterthought once a student has already decided. He said the core problem is rarely a shortage of options, but a shortage of the information students need to choose wisely. He called for replacing traditional, one-time guidance with a continuous system that begins early and helps students discover their interests over time, while introducing them to both academic tracks and vocational and technical specializations.
Tayeh said counselors should not make decisions for students or push them toward specific fields. Instead, their role is to help students understand their strengths, present realistic alternatives, and connect personal ability with market opportunity. He added that guidance must reflect real conditions in the workplace, including how automation and artificial intelligence are reshaping which professions will grow or decline.
Family Pressure Can Undermine Career Choices
Tayeh said families play a decisive role in a student's academic decisions and should support their child's own discovery process rather than imposing a specialization for reasons of social status. He warned that family pressure to pursue a particular field can lead to poor academic performance, loss of motivation, or students abandoning their studies altogether. Family support that comes after consulting specialists, he said, tends to produce better outcomes.
Tayeh called for guidance programs that reach families as well as students, through sessions that explain the range of academic options and labor market trends. He also urged the private sector and media to help shift public perception of vocational and technical careers, arguing that success should not be measured solely by degrees from traditional academic paths.
On overcrowding in specific fields, Tayeh said the answer is not to restrict access, but to understand why students gravitate toward certain specializations, whether from genuine interest, social pressure, a perceived guarantee of employment, or simply a lack of information about alternatives. He called for building a national database tracking academic disciplines, graduate numbers, job demand and future skills needs, so that students and families can base decisions on data rather than assumptions.
A Three-Part Framework: Passion, Ability and Market Demand
Mohammed Abu Amara, another educational expert, described a student's choice of academic field as a balance between personal inclination and the current and future needs of the job market. He said relying on interest alone has driven large numbers of students into saturated, stagnant fields.
Abu Amara said sound decision-making rests on three factors working together: what a student loves, what they are capable of, and what the job market needs. Basing a decision on only one of these, he said, risks poor outcomes, either in finding employment or succeeding in the chosen field. He called for wider use of aptitude and psychological testing to help students identify their genuine abilities, arguing that students at this age often lack the maturity to make accurate career decisions given how quickly professions are changing due to technology.
Abu Amara said schools should strengthen career guidance starting in the upper elementary grades, rather than waiting until students have already chosen between academic and vocational tracks. He praised "Career Day" initiatives that bring professionals into schools to expose students directly to different lines of work.
On overcrowding in fields such as medicine and engineering, Abu Amara said reducing enrollment numbers is not enough on its own. He said students need clear, appealing alternatives, along with information on requirements, study duration and advancement opportunities in supporting technical fields.
He pointed to trades such as culinary arts, mechanics, maintenance and construction as professions that can offer solid income and opportunity, particularly as Jordan expands its BTEC vocational education system, which he said has already improved public perception of technical careers. He called for shared responsibility across the Ministry of Education, media, schools and parents in guiding students toward these paths.
Setting Enrollment Standards Based on Market Capacity
Ayesh Al-Nawaisah, an educational expert, said balancing student choice with labor market needs requires clear, published enrollment regulations tied to actual job market capacity, particularly given high unemployment among graduates of traditional disciplines that remain popular despite market saturation. He noted that student enrollment remains heavily concentrated in health, engineering and technology tracks.
Al-Nawaisah said past efforts to set enrollment quotas without adequate public explanation faced resistance, and argued that future changes require sustained awareness campaigns involving government, media and legislative bodies. He said directing students toward needed specializations does not mean limiting their choices, but organizing them within standards that are announced in advance so students know admission rates and field capacity before applying.
He said the success of any such shift depends on clear governance, published standards, and coordinated support from official institutions and the media, in order to align education with labor market needs and reduce unemployment, in line with Jordan's economic modernization vision.
Source: Al-Ghad.
