US experts say reopening Jordan-Syria border double-edged sword

The border crossing is currently operating at limited capacity, but both sides have agreed to begin taking steps to kick start the necessary procedures for the border crossing to open fully. (Photo: J
The border crossing is currently operating at limited capacity, but both sides have agreed to begin taking steps to kick start the necessary procedures for the border crossing to open fully. (Photo: Jordan News)
NEW YORK — On July 27th, Jordan’s Minister of Interior Mazen Al-Faraya and Syria’s Minister of Interior Mohammad Khaled Al-Rahmoun discussed upping the Jordan-Syria border to full capacity, citing the common interest of both nations to reap the economic benefits of increased trade and free movement.اضافة اعلان

The border crossing is currently operating at limited capacity, but both sides have agreed to begin taking steps to kick start the necessary procedures for the border crossing to open fully.

Jordan News spoke with security experts Robert S. Ford, former US Ambassador to Syria from 2011-2014, and Ibrahim Al-Assil, a senior fellow at the Middle East Institute in Washington, who discussed the economic and security implications of the potential move for Jordan and its relationship with the United States.

The Caesar Syria Civilian Protection Act of 2019, also known as the Caesar Act, is a piece of United States legislation that places sanctions on the Syrian government for its war crimes against the Syrian civilian population. Its passage is seen as having crippled Damascus’ ability to trade, the consequences of which rippled across the region, and Jordan was one nation where the economic fallout was most strongly felt. Prior to the Syrian Civil War, Jordan’s exports to Syria ranged from $250-$300 million annually.

If these border-opening discussions come to fruition, this could help Jordan revive its struggling economy, but the threat of the Caesar Act remains in place. Ambassador Ford states, “Reopening the border does not by itself trigger sanctions against Jordanian entities as called for by the Caesar law. However, any Jordanian entity which does business with one of the proscribed Syrian entities could trigger American retaliation as the law provides.”

Assil sees King Abdullah’s recent visit to the United States and private meeting with President Biden this past week as an indication that the Biden Administration is willing to lessen the iron grip placed on its regional allies when it comes to their relations with Syria, telling Jordan News, “I think that it is clear from King Abdullah’s visit that there was an understanding with the Americans that there is a big economic need for Jordan to increase trade with Syria. That would benefit people on both sides – Syrians and Jordanians.”

Assil cautioned that the border reopening could increase Jordan’s vulnerability to security threats on two fronts: the risk of an overflow of drug smuggling across the border given how deeply embedded drug trafficking has become in the Syrian regime economy and (2) the increased security threat that could surface given that Assad remains a central part of the Iranian alliance. He added, “It comes with advantages and disadvantages. There is an economic need for Jordan given all the challenges it's facing now. But at the same time, it comes with geopolitical and security challenges, given that the Iranian threats to Jordan security and the drug smuggling which is an increasing and very dangerous dimension.”

Ambassador Ford also sees the move as part of a larger trend among Arab states to normalize relations with the Assad government, which directly opposes the United States’ security interests in the region. Assil warned that this understanding should not be interpreted as the United States wanting Assad to be fully integrated in the region, stating that easing Caesar Act restrictions is based on a desire for the United States to help Jordan, its closest ally in the region, address the economic challenges it is currently facing.

Ambassador Ford advised against expecting major economic benefits immediately, pointing out that the damage the Syrian economy has sustained over the previous years of fighting will make increased exportation to Jordan and economic growth an “incremental process.”

Read more Opinion & Analysis