Middle East countries do not want to choose between US and China

middle east map
(File photo: Jordan News)
The warm welcome for China’s leader Xi Jinping to Saudi Arabia in December was interpreted by many as a sign of Chinese resurgence in the Middle East and a growing crisis in US-Saudi relations.اضافة اعلان

China has become increasingly active in the Middle East both economically and politically over the past decade. Its approach to the region ranges from actively expanding its reach and influence to warily avoiding the region’s chronic instability.

At the same time, Western, and especially US, perceptions have shifted from viewing China as a benign “free-rider” on the security infrastructure provided by the US to a growing consensus that China now constitutes a threat to Western interests in the Middle East.

As tensions rise in the South China Sea and the Taiwan Strait, and political and economic fissures widen between China and the West, Beijing is likely to become even more active in a Middle East that has become more welcoming. Even as China’s footprint in the region increases, it will continue to calculate each step with the likely US response in mind. 

China’s engagement in the region grew substantially following the announcement of its Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) in 2013, in which the Middle East plays a significant part. Originally focused on trade and investment in the energy sector, Beijing has since diversified its activity. Today it plays an active role in numerous infrastructure projects, smart cities, innovation centers, and 5G-mobile-network projects. Since 2016, China is the region’s largest foreign investor.

Frustrated by US policies in the Middle East, regional leaders, for their part, have started to view Beijing as a more reliable partner as their distrust of Washington mounts. For Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) countries the relationship with China is more strategic than opportunistic. China’s ability to provide both infrastructure and technology fits well with the visions that Gulf leaders are pursuing for their future.  

China’s Digital Silk Road, introduced in 2015, has become a substantial part of its engagement in the region. Saudi Arabia, Egypt, and the UAE have expanded technological cooperation with China in recent years.

With US-China competition over technology intensifying, Chinese technology companies like Huawei are facing significant pushback among countries in the West and are therefore deepening their cooperation in the Middle East.

The shifting equation in the region was clearly demonstrated when the UAE suspended talks on its F-35 fighter jet deal with the US in 2021, promised as a reward for signing the Abraham Accords. The decision was made after a US demand that the UAE give up cooperation with Huawei on its 5G network as a condition for the deal moving forward.
Many countries in the region view China as an important partner that is there to stay. When countries in the Gulf envision their future, they see more China than the US.
The importance of the Chinese president’s visit to Riyadh in December was in the fact that, unlike previous ones, it was strategic for both sides. 

For China, the biggest question remains whether current US global strategy, including Washington’s policy toward China, will lead to US resurgence or a gradual withdrawal from the region. For Saudi Arabia, the UAE, and the other GCC countries, China in many ways fits well with their vision for the future. More than any other player, China is fully equipped to serve as a long-term partner, buying their oil, building their smart cities, and helping them diversify their economies to green energy.

But rather than choosing sides, Saudi Arabia and the UAE are inclined to favor a strategy of multiple partners including the US, China, and others.

As the US works to preserve its leadership role and Europe remains preoccupied with the war in Ukraine and other challenges, China will continue to strengthen its position in the Middle East, including its ties with longstanding US allies. Many countries in the region view China as an important partner that is there to stay. When countries in the Gulf envision their future, they see more China than the US. 

China will likely become more active but is expected to remain cautious as it assesses the implications for its regional and global interests of recent developments in the Middle East. The US might well be changing its strategic approach in the Middle East, but it will remain a dominant regional player in the coming years. New regional groupings, such as the I2U2 comprising India, Israel, the UAE, and the US, provide Washington with an opportunity to play a positive role and reshape its regional position.

The US should work to alleviate concerns among its partners in the Middle East that any pivot to Asia will come at their expense by supporting such partnerships. Another idea could be to expand the Indo-Pacific Economic Framework to include the UAE as well as other Arab Gulf countries and Israel. 

By moving away from the zero-sum game of superpower competition in the Middle East, the US can advance a broader agenda that would be welcomed by its allies in the region and bring Asia and the Middle East closer together.

Gedaliah Afterman is head of the Asia policy program at the Abba Eban Institute for Diplomacy and Foreign Affairs at Reichman University (IDC Herzliya), Israel.

Read more Opinion and Analysis
Jordan News