The final hours of the COP31 climate summit reshaped the boundaries of disagreement over how to tackle the climate crisis, as negotiations on Saturday turned into a political confrontation over the cost of moving away from fossil fuels and the responsibility of developed countries to finance the transition to clean energy. Consensus on a comprehensive decision remained elusive, with the conference extending beyond its scheduled closing time.
Tensions intensified on Saturday after the European Union warned that the negotiations could fail and consultations scheduled for heads of delegations were cancelled. The Turkish presidency stepped up its contacts to prepare a third draft of the decision in an attempt to salvage consensus, which had been obstructed by disagreements over fossil fuels and adaptation finance.
An earlier draft of the overarching decision had revealed a retreat from references to transitioning away from conventional energy sources, while detailed financial commitments were deferred to later stages.
The discussions showed that the divide was no longer limited to the level of climate ambition, but had extended to determining who would bear the cost of implementing it. Jordan maintained its position against shifting the economic burden onto energy-importing countries, insisting that financing and technology must be provided before additional obligations are imposed.
Experts and civil society representatives warned that the gap between international pledges and the actual needs of developing countries was widening, particularly in addressing drought, water scarcity and extreme weather events. The fair distribution of financial burdens emerged as one of the most contentious issues in the negotiations.
Fair Distribution of Responsibilities
Bilal Al-Shaqareen, head of Jordan’s negotiating team and director of the Climate Change Directorate at the Ministry of Environment, said Jordan’s position on negotiations over moving away from fossil fuels is based on the need to take countries’ economic and development capacities into account and avoid imposing commitments that exceed their actual capabilities.
Speaking to Al Ghad, Al-Shaqareen stressed that addressing the climate crisis requires a fair distribution of responsibilities rather than placing additional burdens on developing countries that lack the resources to bear them.
He explained that calls to restrict fossil fuel use cannot be separated from the energy needs of developing countries. He cited figures indicating that around 65% of Africa’s population does not have access to electricity, making restrictions on conventional energy sources, without providing affordable alternatives, a major challenge.
He also noted that any additional obligations imposed on oil-producing countries could affect prices in global markets. Producers would likely pass the resulting costs on to importers and end consumers rather than absorb them directly.
Al-Shaqareen pointed out that this possibility carries particular economic implications for Jordan, which relies on imports for most of its fuel needs. This makes the country vulnerable to additional financial burdens resulting from any potential rise in prices, potentially placing such measures at odds with national economic interests.
Regarding the negotiations, Al-Shaqareen said the European Union had succeeded in retaining the target of increasing electrification to 35% by 2035 in the draft texts under discussion. However, the bloc is seeking to add conditions ensuring that the electricity used is clean, meaning it is generated from sources that do not rely on fossil fuels.
He said the disagreement is not about the principle of transitioning to clean energy itself, but rather the financial and technological requirements needed to make that transition possible.
He stressed that developed countries must fulfil their responsibilities by supporting developing nations and providing the financing and technology required to transform their energy systems. Such support would make the transition to clean electricity a feasible and acceptable option without imposing commitments that exceed national capabilities.
Al-Shaqareen confirmed that the Arab Group is pursuing a unified negotiating approach on these issues, despite differences in the member states’ interests and underlying objectives.
He explained that some countries are primarily concerned with protecting economies that depend on oil production, while others, including Jordan, are focused on avoiding the economic burden of rising energy costs and securing the financial and technological support needed to transition to more sustainable energy sources.
Weakening the Message
Ruba Ajjour, head of the Climate Change Department at the Royal Scientific Society, who has been following the negotiations, said removing references to fossil fuels from the draft overarching decision would weaken the summit’s central message.
Speaking to Al Ghad, Ajjour noted that at COP29 in Dubai, countries had agreed to transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems in a just, orderly and equitable manner. She said COP31 had therefore been expected to produce clear implementation mechanisms to translate that direction into practical and measurable steps.
Drawing on her work in preparing greenhouse gas emissions inventories and developing mitigation scenarios, she stressed the importance of implementing international agreements and measuring their impact at the national level.
Regarding the draft decision’s provision calling for a threefold increase in adaptation finance by 2035, while postponing agreement on detailed figures and the baseline year until the next COP32 summit in Addis Ababa, Ajjour explained that 2035 represents the target deadline for reaching the climate finance goal agreed at COP29: at least $300 billion annually for developing countries, led by developed nations.
However, she said her main concern was how much funding would actually reach developing countries before that deadline and what conditions would accompany it.
She gave the example of a municipality seeking to protect its neighbourhoods from flash floods, or a water sector requiring urgent investment to address drought. In such cases, the timing of funding is decisive in determining what can be implemented immediately and what will remain delayed.
Ajjour therefore believes the highest priority should be establishing a clear upward trajectory for financial flows starting now, simplifying access procedures and allocating a larger share to grants and concessional financing, particularly for climate adaptation projects that protect lives and essential public services, even if they do not generate direct financial returns.
Based on her monitoring of the negotiations in Antalya, she said it had become clear that the focus was shifting towards implementation, an important and necessary direction after years of setting targets and developing plans.
Nevertheless, the negotiations showed that major disagreements remain over three key issues: emissions reductions, the amount of financial support available to developing countries, and the mechanisms for accessing it.
She stressed that the true value of any international agreement should not be measured by the wording of its decisions, but by the tools and resources it makes available to countries once the conference ends.
Drawing on her practical experience in preparing transparency reports in Jordan, Ajjour said the country has the capacity to accurately document progress, identify implementation delays and determine the support needed to overcome them. She added that such data gains real practical value when used to direct funding towards actual priorities and address the causes of delays on the ground.
As for Jordan, Ajjour said the outcomes of these negotiations would have a tangible and direct impact, given the country’s need to direct investment towards strengthening water security, protecting cities from heatwaves and flash floods, and supporting farmers’ resilience to drought, alongside expanding renewable energy projects and improving energy efficiency.
She noted that Jordan has an established knowledge base in emissions data and tracking progress on climate action. This can be used alongside climate risk assessment information to identify intervention priorities accurately, estimate their financial costs and measure their actual impact on people’s lives.
She added that delays in funding or complicated access requirements narrow the scope for implementation in Jordan and many other developing countries.
Ajjour said citizens measure the value of international climate summits by how much their outcomes affect their cities and public services, and by their country’s ability to strengthen resilience against drought, heatwaves and flash floods.
The Cost of Stalled Negotiations
Omar Al-Shoushan, head of the Union of Environmental Associations, said COP31 negotiations had continued beyond their scheduled deadline, while disagreements over emissions reductions and adaptation finance remained unresolved.
In Jordan, the cost of this deadlock is reflected in growing pressure on water supplies, farmers’ incomes and municipal budgets, which bear the consequences of flash floods, according to Al-Shoushan.
He said this raises questions about how these risks can be managed within Jordan’s available resources and how the country can use its international relationships to secure the financing and technology it needs.
Speaking to Al Ghad, Al-Shoushan noted that the negotiations had exposed the difficulty of building on the agreement reached at COP29 to transition away from fossil fuels. References to that commitment were removed from one of the later drafts, while a numerical target for adaptation finance that had appeared in an earlier version was also absent.
He said this development came amid a strong presence of oil and gas companies and affiliated organisations, while the absence of the US government delegation weakened the political momentum of the negotiations.
Al-Shoushan warned that continued uncertainty over the amount of funding, its conditions and when it will become available could turn the world’s leading climate negotiating platform into an arena for accumulating further promises and disappointments for countries already bearing the costs of drought, floods and heatwaves.
At the national level, he called for a rethink of how Jordan manages its climate agenda and for climate risks to be integrated into the heart of economic decision-making. This requires managing priorities at Cabinet level, providing the Ministry of Environment with the necessary technical expertise, and incorporating climate risk assessments into budget preparation and approval of major projects.
He argued that investment in increasing water supplies should be accompanied by a clear assessment of potential savings from reducing water losses, as well as a comparison of the cost of each cubic metre under both approaches. Similarly, when approving urban expansion, flash flood risk maps should be incorporated into licensing decisions and infrastructure design.
Al-Shoushan stressed that Jordan’s updated Nationally Determined Contribution, which aims to reduce emissions by 31% by 2035 compared with the adopted baseline, provides a framework for measuring emissions reduction efforts.
He identified the next step as translating Royal directives on climate finance into a multi-year investment programme that also includes adaptation. Each project should have a clearly defined cost, implementing agency, funding source and expected results.
Grants could be directed towards public prevention services, such as early warning systems and protecting neighbourhoods exposed to flash floods. Concessional financing could be used for projects that deliver measurable savings, such as improving the efficiency of water pumping and energy use, according to Al-Shoushan.
He explained that publishing results annually would allow municipalities, environmental associations and oversight bodies to monitor the real-world impact of spending.
In his view, partnerships with the European Union and its member states offer an opportunity to begin this process. During the Dead Sea Investment Conference, Jordan presented 41 investment opportunities worth approximately $15 billion across several sectors, including water, renewable energy and electricity storage.
The European Union and the European Investment Bank also announced a grant of €7.5 million aimed at mobilising around €130 million in green and digital investments, Al-Shoushan said.
He believes this approach could be accompanied by the selection of specific projects, such as reducing water losses and developing solar energy projects combined with storage. Agreements could then be reached with European partners to prepare and finance these projects, transfer technology and train Jordanian professionals.
At the regional level, Jordan can promote Arab and Mediterranean cooperation that places water scarcity among the priorities for adaptation finance and develops joint early warning programmes and data-sharing mechanisms, Al-Shoushan added.
He called for a change in the prevailing approach to climate change management in Jordan through economic investment by directing public spending towards prevention, political action by using international relationships to secure financing and technology transfer, and technical efforts by drawing on the expertise of institutions, universities and municipalities to prepare and implement projects.
He said the crisis affects all citizens, whether through irregular water supplies to their homes, extreme weather events confronting farmers, economic losses, rising electricity and food costs, or public services that are unable to withstand heatwaves and flash floods.